{"id":26477,"date":"2015-02-27T13:20:00","date_gmt":"2015-02-27T17:20:00","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/?p=26477"},"modified":"2015-02-27T13:20:00","modified_gmt":"2015-02-27T17:20:00","slug":"joseph-alsop-papers-in-arb-part-2-joe-alsops-greek-bronze-age-archive-at-the-university-of-cincinnati","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/2015\/02\/joseph-alsop-papers-in-arb-part-2-joe-alsops-greek-bronze-age-archive-at-the-university-of-cincinnati\/","title":{"rendered":"Joseph Alsop Papers in ARB – Part 2 – Joe Alsop's Greek Bronze Age Archive at the University of Cincinnati"},"content":{"rendered":"

Below is the second in a series of blogs in which Jack Davis discusses Joseph Alsop and his papers in ARB. \u00a0It\u00a0was originally published on From the Archivist\u2019s Notebook<\/a>, a blog of\u00a0Natalia Vogeikoff-Brogan, head of the archives at the American School of Classical Studies at Athens. \u00a0<\/em><\/p>\n

By: \u00a0Jack Davis,\u00a0Carl W. Blegen Professor of Greek Archaeology at the University of Cincinnati\u00a0<\/em><\/p>\n

\"fromthesilentearth\"<\/a>Searching library catalogues and online archival finding aids sometimes produces unexpected consequences. As I wrote in Part I of this two-part post, Joseph Alsop\u2019s principal archive is curated in the Library of Congress. The University of Cincinnati Archives and Rare Book Library, however, contains five boxes of manuscripts of\u00a0From the Silent Earth<\/em> and relevant correspondence between Alsop and the eminent scholars Emmett Bennett, Carl Blegen, Maurice Bowra, John Caskey, Sterling Dow, and Leonard Palmer. While writing From the Silent Earth<\/em>: A Political Columnist Reports on the Greek Bronze Age<\/em> (1964), Alsop solicited advice from these distinguished Aegean prehistorians and Classical philologists, all of whom were supportive of his efforts. Jack Caskey, for example, replied to an initial letter of inquiry: \u201cI\u2019m particularly interested in absorbing your political analysis. It sounds neither foolish nor pretentious to me in your brief summary.\u201d<\/p>\n

In Part I, I explored how it was that one of Washington\u2019s foremost political analysts of the Cold War era (and for two decades a trustee of the American School of Classical Studies in Athens) came to write a book about the Greek Bronze Age. In Part II, I describe the contents of the archive in Cincinnati, discuss its academic significance, and consider what light it sheds on Alsop\u2019s research methods.<\/p>\n

Four of five boxes (#1-3 and 5) either contain drafts of Alsop\u2019s 1962 article about Blegen in The New Yorker <\/em>or\u00a0From the Silent Earth<\/em>.\u00a0In several instances, the manuscripts are annotated in the hands of the aforementioned scholars, who served as Alsop\u2019s unofficial advisory panel. The most valuable part of the archive consists of letters in Box 4, in which views are expressed about Aegean prehistory that Alsop\u2019s correspondents\u00a0might have been reluctant to put in print. We find in them an entr\u00e9e into the world of academic politics at a time when debate over the dating of Linear B tablets found by Sir Arthur Evans at Knossos was raging.<\/p>\n

\"Alsop's<\/a>

Alsop\u2019s \u201cA Pylos Before A Pylos,\u201d The New Yorker, Nov. 30, 1962<\/p><\/div>\n

The correspondence with Sir Cecil Maurice Bowra (1898-1971) is most extensive, since this\u00a0relationship was long-standing and operated simultaneously on social as well as\u00a0academic planes. Five days after Kennedy\u2019s assassination Alsop wrote to Bowra: \u201cI feel exactly as though I were in a room in which the light had very abruptly irrationally and permanently gone out.\u201dAlsop\u00a0was condescendingly frank about\u00a0the scholars who had helped him write From the Silent Earth<\/em>. Referring\u00a0to the dinner in Georgetown planned for December 14, 1963 (see Part I), he remarked to\u00a0Bowra: \u201cI wish you might be here, for you have helped me more than anyone but I am not quite sure that you would enjoy Professor and Mrs. C.C. Vermeule, Dr. Alison Frantz, Professor and Mrs. Sterling Dow, Professor and Mrs. E. L. Bennett, Jr., just as I am not entirely sure Susan Mary will enjoy them.\u201d He\u00a0was more excited about the prospect of having Bowra attend a dinner the following month: \u201cAre there others you want to see, other than the [McGeorge] Bundys, the [Dean] Achesons \u2026 We have asked our grandest and most monstrous monster the Secretary of Defense, Bob McNamara, to the dinner on Monday. I plan to ask the President, too, not for our sake, I must rudely add, but because I think he will greatly enjoy meeting you.\u201d<\/p>\n

\"Alsop<\/a>

Alsop writing to Bowra about President Kennedy\u2019s assassination (Archives and Rare Book Library, University of Cincinnati)<\/p><\/div>\n

Both Bowra and Alsop were\u00a0fond of gossip, archaeological and political. Alsop commented\u00a0snidely on the chronological scheme proposed for the dating of beehive tombs at Mycenae by\u00a0George Mylonas, professor at Washington University in St. Louis, \u201cBlegen was critical of it in detail, just as Mylonas is even more critical of Blegen.\u201d Bowra could be more caustic. \u00a0He had no respect for the Duke of Edinburgh, Moses Finley, or especially for T.B.L. Webster (whom he called a \u201cpoop\u201d).<\/p>\n

Confidences are shared. \u00a0A humorous remark\u00a0by Bowra about the Profumo Affair implies that these two men, though closeted, were open with each other about their sexual orientation: \u201cSandys name is much in the news. You no doubt saw the admirable letter in \u2018The Observer\u2019 pointing out what a grave security risk heterosexuals are in high office.\u201d (In 1957, the KGB had entrapped Alsop himself in a compromising situation with one \u201cBoris,\u201d and had then attempted to blackmail him with surreptitiously taken photographs.)<\/p>\n

Alsop\u2019s other correspondence is\u00a0more strictly professional and the scholars who helped him write From the Silent Earth<\/em>\u00a0were mostly\u00a0new acquaintances. Nonetheless, their letters to him, and his to them, shed light on his\u00a0methods. He\u00a0was first and foremost a journalist and his technique I would call \u201ccomposition by consultation.\u201d\u00a0\u00a0 In the preface to his book about art collecting, The Rare Art Traditions<\/em>, he claimed\u00a0that he began that work imagining that he would\u00a0\u201cconsult the best authorities in the languages known to [him] \u2026\u201d. But that strategy was not sufficient, since there was too much subject matter that he could not himself master. He needed to question experts. For\u00a0From the Silent Earth <\/em>he, for example, needed to ask Emmett Bennett about Mycenaean warfare, the House of the Oil Merchant at Mycenae, Mycenaean dress\u2014also where\u00a0Pa-ki-ja-na, <\/em>a religious center referenced in Linea B tablets from Pylos, was located,\u00a0and how he should imagine it.<\/p>\n

\"Bowra<\/a>

Bowra advising Alsop on issues of Mycenaean chronology (Archives and Rare Book Library, University of Cincinnati)<\/p><\/div>\n

\"Eugene<\/a>

Eugene Vanderpool and Sterling Dow, Greece 1963<\/p><\/div>\n

Sterling Dow was Alsop\u2019s real guiding light, recommending\u00a0From the Silent Earth<\/i>\u00a0to Harper and Row and critiquing the entire manuscript. In this period of his life Dow was studying early Greek literacy, an interest that culminated in his 1971 contribution (with John Chadwick) to the second edition of the Cambridge Ancient History<\/em>. A comradery quickly developed, and Alsop and Dow\u00a0planned to travel to Crete together in the summer of 1963. Alsop confided\u00a0in Dow: \u201cI don\u2019t want to be sentimental but at my age it is not often that one seems to have made a new friend and I do feel that in your case.\u201d<\/p>\n

But the exchanges between Carl Blegen and Alsop are of particular academic interest since\u00a0they shed light on a supposed \u201cquarrel\u201d between\u00a0Sir Arthur Evans and\u00a0Alan Wace, a subject that has been explored in two recent studies published in N. Vogeikoff-Brogan, J. L. Davis, and V. Florou, eds., Carl W. Blegen: Personal and Archaeological Narratives<\/em> [Lockwood Press, 2015], one by Yannis Fappas (\u201cThe \u2018Govs\u2019 of Mycenaean Archaeology: The Friendship and Collaboration of Carl W. Blegen and Alan J. B. Wace as Seen through their Correspondence\u201d), the other by Yannis Galanakis (\u201c\u2019Islanders vs. Mainlanders,\u2019 \u2018The Mycenae Wars,\u2019 and Other Short\u00a0Stories: An Archival Visit to an Old Debate\u201d). \u00a0As Aegean prehistorians well know, Wace and Blegen strongly disagreed with Evans about the nature of the relationship between Crete and the Greek mainland in the earlier centuries of the Late Bronze Age. They contested Evans\u2019 claim that Crete had been culturally and\u00a0<\/em>politically dominant over the mainland since the time of the Schliemann Shaft Graves at Mycenae.<\/p>\n

Such differences of opinion, in\u00a0Galanakis\u2019s words,\u201csoon turned into an academic and public controversy,\u00a0especially after Wace\u2019s first excavation season at Mycenae in 1920. In an article published in The Illustrated London News<\/em>\u00a0that same year, and written by Evans\u2019s friend, David Hogarth, we read: \u2018Islanders, led by British Cretans, offer battle to Mainlanders, led by British Athenians. Might not deeper examination show that the Argolid developed its own culture from the Stone Age up to the capacity to produce for itself the jewels of the Shaft Graves? The dispute will be conducted according to the rules of scientific war\u2014war of the kind that brings peace, not a sword, and light out of darkness.\u2019\u201d By the 1950s the debate hinged on the date of the Linear B tablets Evans had found at Knossos. \u00a0Were they really as early as 1450 B.C.? \u00a0A challenge to Evan\u2019s methods, even his personal integrity, was fueled by the decipherment of Linear B as Greek in 1952. The large cache of Linear B tablets found by Blegen in the Palace of Nestor at Pylos came from destruction levels, ca. 1200 B.C., apparently much later than those at Knossos.<\/p>\n

\"The<\/a>

The Waces in Cambridge in the 1930s (ASCSA Archives, Carl W. Blegen Papers)<\/p><\/div>\n

Such was the professional and public face of the controversy. But what happened behind the scenes? Galanakis has concluded that: \u201cDespite profound disagreement on archaeological matters, the archival material I was able to examine suggests that personal relations between Evans and the \u2018Govs\u2019 (i.e., Wace and Blegen) remained very good.\u00a0Some scholars have suggested that Wace\u2019s career suffered because of this archaeological\u00a0dispute and that it was Evans who was ultimately responsible for the \u2018sudden\u00a0halt,\u2019 as they describe it, of Wace\u2019s work at Mycenae and the termination of his tenure as director of the British School in 1923.\u00a0Yet the view one gets from the letters is\u00a0quite different: Wace knew a year and a half in advance that both his directorship\u00a0and the Mycenae excavations would come to an end. Moreover, in one of the letters\u00a0to Evans, Wace asked him \u2018whether I could give your name as one of my referees,\u00a0when on my return to England, I will start applying for jobs.\u2019 In 1934, Evans would\u00a0support Wace\u2019s application for the Laurence Chair in Classical Archaeology at Cambridge:\u00a0\u2018I am glad to enclose your recommendation for this post, though I really do\u00a0not think you need it!\u2019\u00a0(referring to the recommendation letter, not the post).\u201d<\/p>\n

Yet correspondence between Alsop and Blegen suggests that Evans may actually have<\/em> impeded the development of\u00a0Wace\u2019s career. Since drama made good reading, Alsop had in first drafts chosen to emphasize conflict between Wace and Evans, thus evoking strong reactions from Blegen. Blegen wrote in response,\u00a0in October 1962 when he received Alsop\u2019s draft of \u201cA Pylos Before Pylos\u201d: \u201cI wonder if it wouldn\u2019t be wise to soft-pedal that charge resurrected by Palmer that Evans blocked Wace\u2019s reappointment as Director of the British School.\u00a0 There were some factors that Palmer didn\u2019t mention.\u00a0The British School had a regulation limiting the tenure of a Director to two terms of three years each.\u00a0 Wace had already had three terms, since he was in Athens during the First World War and was lent to the Legation for many years of war service.\u00a0Alan Wace and I were intimate friends; we worked together in each other\u2019s excavations, collaborated on several articles, and discussed all our problems.\u00a0 We agreed fully on archaeological matters and I always sided with him on other questions.\u00a0 I hoped the Committee would changed their rules and give him a fourth term, but they didn\u2019t.\u00a0 I can see no great profit to anyone in reviving that episode.\u00a0 Why not leave it to Palmer?\u201d<\/p>\n

\"Blegen<\/a>

Blegen to Alsop, Oct. 1, 1962 (Archives and Rare Book Library, University of Cincinnati)<\/p><\/div>\n

The following year, while writing\u00a0From the Silent Earth<\/em>, Alsop returned to the subject, writing to Blegen in August 1963: \u201cAs to the matter of Wace\u2019s failure to be reappointed to the Directorship of the British School, I know I have been a little obstinate about this, because Maurice Bowra and all my other English friends who happen to be acquainted with the inside story, have told me that Wace would unquestionably have been reappointed except for Sir Arthur Evan\u2019s venomous opposition.\u00a0 The anecdotes of the Evans-Wace episode are indeed fairly hair-raising, but only as they relate to Sir Arthur, I should add.\u201d In the end, however, Alsop relented, and Blegen thanked him for doing so in October 1963: \u201cI was glad to see your new version dealing with Evans: it is, in my judgment, a great improvement over what you first wrote (which seemed to me to reflect too much of Palmer\u2019s coloring) and more in line with the facts.\u00a0\u00a0Wace had already served three terms as Director.\u00a0\u00a0We were always, he and I, very close friends and I\u2019m sure he would prefer the revised text.\u201d Blegen did not, however, deny the accuracy of Bowra\u2019s views or of Alsop\u2019s original text.<\/p>\n

\"The<\/a>

The ASCSA centennial brochure<\/p><\/div>\n

I end this, the second part of my post, with more general thoughts about Joseph Alsop and Greece. It is not hard for me to understand his love for ancient Greece, since he was the product of an educational system that emphasized the significance of the Classical tradition. But, as a political analyst too, Alsop had a long-standing interest in modern Greece. Two \u201cMatter of Fact\u201d columns, written in February 1947 with his brother Stewart, had exposed the extent of Truman\u2019s concern over Communist infiltration in the Balkans, reporting that the United States\u00a0was considering a \u201cpolitico-economic fire brigade\u201d to deal with problems. Alsop had also been influential in building public opinion in the United States in support of the Marshall Plan, against the opposition of Senator Robert Taft in particular. \u00a0Brother Stewart had traveled to Greece in these years.<\/p>\n

For the preceding reasons it seems hardly a\u00a0surprise that Alsop\u2019s associations with Greece lasted\u00a0long after the publication of From the Silent Earth<\/em>. He continued to correspond with Blegen until 1966, their final exchange being at the time of Elizabeth Blegen\u2019s death in November of that year. After his retirement in 1974 he became even more involved in Greek affairs as a trustee of ASCSA (1965-1985). In that role he worked diligently with Betsy Whitehead, president of the Board of Trustees, to build the School\u2019s endowment in its centennial campaign and he was responsible for arranging a\u00a0congratulatory telegram from President Reagan. In the early 1980s he conducted a vigorous academic correspondence with fellow trustee Malcolm Wiener, once again on the subject of Mycenaean Knossos among others. Men like\u00a0Alsop, though little known to scholars who today use ASCSA\u2019s facilities in Athens, have worked since its foundation in 1881 to make the School what is today \u2014 a worldclass center of academic excellence that continues to thrive, even in challenging financial environments. They deserve our gratitude and remembrance.<\/p>\n

\"Alsop's<\/a>

Alsop\u2019s introductory remarks in the ASCSA centennial brochure, 1981<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

<\/div>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

Below is the second in a series of blogs in which Jack Davis discusses Joseph Alsop and his papers in ARB. \u00a0It\u00a0was originally published on From the Archivist\u2019s Notebook, a blog of\u00a0Natalia Vogeikoff-Brogan, head of the archives at the American … Continue reading →<\/span><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":5,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[3,13],"tags":[712,711,67],"class_list":["post-26477","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-arb","category-uclibraries","tag-archeology","tag-classics","tag-rare-books"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/26477","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/5"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=26477"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/26477\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=26477"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=26477"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/libapps.libraries.uc.edu\/liblog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=26477"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}